Buy Chocolate

For more on best chocolate subscription boxes a uk guide to monthly discovery, check out our guide.

You know that feeling when you’re staring down a thirty-six-ounce jar of chocolate spread at Costco and wondering if it’s actually any good or just massive? I’ve been there more times than I care to admit. This guide breaks down every chocolate spread worth buying at Costco right now — because value doesn’t mean much if the taste isn’t there.

Costco’s warehouse model practically begs you to buy chocolate spread in bulk. The per-ounce savings are real, but you’re also committing to a container the size of a small dog. So which ones deliver on flavour and which ones sit at the back of your pantry until 2028?

Nutella: The Costco King

Nutella is the reason most people even look at the chocolate spread aisle at Costco. The 6.6-pound twin-pack runs around $18.99 at most US locations — that’s roughly $1.44 per pound.

Compare that to a standard 13-ounce jar at a regular grocery store for $5.49, and you’re saving about forty percent. The formula’s exactly the same: hazelnuts, skim milk, cocoa, sugar, and palm oil. Same spread, lower price.

I’ve bought this twin-pack more times than I’ll admit. It lasts my household about three months, assuming nobody sneaks spoonfuls at midnight.

Kirkland Signature Organic Chocolate Spread

Costco’s house brand doesn’t mess around. The Kirkland Signature Organic Chocolate Spread comes in a 26-ounce jar for about $9.99. That’s competitive with Nutella on a per-ounce basis, and it’s certified organic.

The big difference? This one skips palm oil. Instead, it uses sunflower oil and coconut oil as the fat base. The texture’s slightly less firm than Nutella — softer at room temperature, which makes spreading on toast almost effortless.

Personally, I prefer the Kirkland version for baking. The organic cocoa gives it a deeper flavour that doesn’t get lost in brownies or overnight oats.

Biscoff Cookie Spread: The Dark Horse

Wait — this isn’t chocolate. You’re right. But Costco often stocks the Biscoff Cookie Spread right next to the chocolate options, and it’s worth mentioning because it’s genuinely excellent and pairs beautifully with chocolate spreads.

A two-pack runs about $11.99. The flavour’s like liquefied speculoos cookies — cinnamon, brown sugar, caramelised notes. I mix it with Nutella on toast for what my family calls “the perfect breakfast.”

If you’re strict about chocolate-only, skip this section. But if you’re adventurous, grab one.

How the Costco Chocolate Spreads Compare

Let’s put them side by side. Per tablespoon, Nutella has 200 calories, 11 grams of fat, and 21 grams of sugar. The Kirkland organic version clocks in at 190 calories, 12 grams of fat, and 19 grams of sugar per serving — slightly better on the sugar front.

Nutella spreads more smoothly straight from the fridge. The Kirkland version stiffens up more when chilled, so you’ll want to let it sit out for five minutes before using.

For taste, Nutella wins on that familiar hazelnut-forward profile we all grew up with. The Kirkland version tastes more like real cocoa — less sweet, more grown-up. I think the Kirkland one is the better choice if you’re an adult who finds Nutella a bit cloying. There, I said it.

Is Costco Chocolate Spread Worth the Bulk?

You need to eat chocolate spread somewhat regularly for Costco bulk to make sense. The twin-pack Nutella has a shelf life of about nine months unopened and three months after opening. If you’re a once-a-month user, you’ll throw half of it away.

That’s not a value. It’s waste.

For families or committed spread enthusiasts — people who put chocolate spread on pancakes, waffles, toast, fruit, and straight-up spoons — Costco pricing is unbeatable. The per-serving cost drops by nearly half compared to standard grocery store jars.

Check out our guide to the best chocolate spread on Amazon for more options if Costco isn’t convenient.

What Costco Could Improve

Costco’s chocolate spread selection is honestly limited. You get Nutella, the Kirkland organic option, and that’s basically it for pure chocolate spreads. There’s no dark chocolate version, no high-protein option, and nothing sugar-free.

For comparison, a standard supermarket carries ten to fifteen chocolate spread products. Costco carries two. The trade-off is price versus variety.

I’d love to see Costco stock a dark chocolate hazelnut spread. The demand is clearly there. My personal hope is they pick up something like Rigoni di Asiago Nocciolata — an organic dark chocolate option that would fit their premium brand strategy perfectly.

The Verdict

Standing in that Costco aisle with a two-pack of Nutella in one hand and the Kirkland organic in the other, here’s my honest take. Get the Kirkland organic if you want something less sweet with real cocoa flavour. Get the Nutella twin-pack if you’re feeding kids or need the classic taste everyone recognises.

Either way, you’re saving money compared to the grocery store. Just make sure you have the pantry space and the appetite. Buy an extra jar of quality chocolate while you’re at it — you’ll find plenty of uses for both. Because the real question isn’t whether Costco chocolate spread is worth it. It’s whether your willpower can handle having that much chocolate spread in the house. Mine can’t. And honestly? I’m okay with that.

Chocolate Hazelnut Spread Guide